Should the Government Pay for Birth Control?

Everyone is looking forward to change under the Obama administration. Some dream of universal health care, others of Supreme Court appointees who will protect Roe v. Wade, and still others for federal action on the gay marriage issue.

But one of the most controversial issues to come out of the current administration isn’t any of the above. Rather, the emergence of Bristol Palin as abstinence education’s spokeswoman will bring another reproductive issue—government-subsidized birth control—to the fore.

Children of the Revolution
Following the sexual revolution of the 1960s, college campuses have been able to provide students with affordable and effective birth control methods because of agreements with pharmaceutical companies. The 2005 Deficit Reduction Act, however, effectively made it more difficult for drug companies to offer these large discounts.

Since then, brand name contraceptive pills and devices have jumped in price. What was once an affordable three to ten dollar monthly expense for college students—less than they would probably have spent on beer and coffee—is now thirty to fifty dollars, according to TIME reporter Kate Rooney. And because college students won’t stop having sex any time soon, despite Ms. Palin’s most valiant efforts on that front, these high costs bring with them a new set of problems.

Plan B
The most recent public kerfuffle over contraception focused around Plan B emergency contraception, also known as the morning after pill. Consequent from that debate and despite protests of those who say that Plan B is abortion lite, the morning after pill is now more readily available than primary contraception. It is unclear whether the rise in Plan B’s use is due to its increased availability or the higher costs of birth control pills and devices, but both factors probably play a role.

With young women being turned away from their college health clinics empty-handed because they can’t afford pills or intrauterine devices (IUDs), the burden of cost falls to other outlets, like Planned Parenthood, in the form of Plan B, abortions, and in some cases, unwanted children.

He Said, She Said
The original version of the 2010 budget proposal sent to Congress by the Obama administration included the Medicaid Family Planning State Option, which would have set aside $200 million for reproductive health care coverage in an effort to forestall the approximately $9.1 billion of taxpayer money that goes to teen pregnancy costs every year.

3 readers liked this story.
share
POST
08.24.2009
Jollyegirl
You make a very good point. We want the govenernment involved to a certain point but then, we want them to butt out when it doesn't really make sense for them to. As a taxpayer, I don't think they have the right to tell me that I can't have birth control but on the other hand, I don't think I should have to pay for some stupid woman who got knocked up because she was being irresponsible. I think it all goes back to personal responsibility which is something that we, as a nation, don't really push. I think that people should have to be responsible for their own actions and that other people shouldn't judge them because you don't know what you would do in someone else's shoes. I just wish that people would accept responsibility for their actions. I think we need more education but with contraceptives and abstinence not just one or the other.
06.26.2009
Juniper
No more govt involved in my body! I dont want the government funding anything to do with birth control OR drugs to help get pregant (for wo/men both) The more we rely on the govt, the more say they have in telling me what I 'should' have done versus what I think is right for me. At least I can negotiate w/ the insurance company.
06.26.2009
Linda
I am sorry to say I did not read your article. But, I will give my opinion. THE PILL is not the only form of birth control. There a other ways to prevent "not the time" pregnancy and God knows people of all ages and races and countries are NOT USING THEM. The government can PAY FOR THEM ALL THEY WANT, it is the PEOPLE HAVE TO REMEMBER TO "USE THEM." This is a subject that has been around for way too long. A fact of life that is in the news daily. Children having children. Single Mom's not only having one, buy as many as they want to. I think the government is not at fault for this. It is the way people decide on their own to live their lives. And it is only getting worse.
06.24.2009
Mary
If not the government, insurance should--and even after the pill, when you need hormone replacement, that's not covered under insurance either and it's not cheap.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Relationships Play Style Career & Money Neighborhood & World