Best Dog for the Job: Choosing the Right Breed

With more than 150 dog breeds to select from, choosing a dog is not an easy task, nor should it be. The more time you take learning about dog breeds and considering your own needs and personality traits (thinking of this as your breeding!), the better match you’ll make.

Dogs have been bred for hundreds of years—or in the cases of several breeds, such as the New Guinea singing dog, for thousands of years—for specific purposes and demeanors. You can take a dog away from its ancestral “job,” but you often can’t take the job out of the dog. A herder will always herd, even if it’s rounding up toddlers and has never seen a sheep in its life.

When considering a new dog, I always consider my lifestyle first and then find breeds that fit well with it. Is your home spacious or just this side of a postage stamp? Do you have a yard or is the closest park blocks away? Do you imagine jogging with your dog, or is curling up in front of the TV more your idea of perfect companionship? Would black fur on a white rug horrify or endear you? And what will your Siamese think when you bring Buddy home?

Following are some of the issues to take into consideration and some potential breeds, though they represent just a few choices among many.

Hot and Cold: Breeds for Extreme Climates
Not surprisingly, dogs with thick or long hair are best suited for colder climates and fare less well in hot or humid ones. St. Bernards, Newfoundlands, Akitas, Samoyeds, Siberian huskies, German shepherds, Bernese mountain dogs, and Old English sheepdogs are all excellent choices if you’re moving to Juneau or Buffalo.

For hot weather, look not only for dogs with shorter hair, but also those with longer faces. Dogs with short faces, such as the Pug, have a more difficult time panting, the method used by dogs to get rid of excess body heat. Good choices for subtropical climes include Schnauzers, Beagles, Weimaraners, Dobermans, Chihuahuas, and Greyhounds.

7 readers liked this story.
share
POST
07.11.2009
Anna D*
What a wonderful article indeed! Must read for anyone considering getting a dog. I volunteer at a local animal shelter and I see so many times people pick a dog just because he or she is cute ignoring their obvious issues or complete uncomatibilty (breed, size, temperment, level of activity etc.). Since people make a mistake of not picking the right dog, every day at least a few dogs are being brought to the shelter, which is very sad.
06.26.2009
Juniper
Great article. I live in a military community overseas and I often read the ads of people selling their pets because they dont have time, didnt realize it wasnt good for kids, didnt fit into their stairwell home. We're choosing a mini-daschund next year because of her size (portable for a military lifestyle), acceptance at hotels, ease of leisure travel. We may be surprised at her bark potential but that's just good training after that. I cant wait to have my right dog.
06.26.2009
XMasBaby74
Great advice that anyone considering a dog should read. I adopted a Border Collie mix/mutt from the pound in January and she herds her Siamese siblings and any smaller, docile dog she meets. The term toddler mosh pit is adorable, and my dog is only truly happy in life with lots of noise, activity, and children. She loves to "mosh." Her activity level is one I have a hard time keeping up with and not being a retriever by nature, I took me over a month of daily training to get her to play fetch. She now loves it. Extreme summers in Arizona make long walks and playing fetch outside difficult, so we use our hallway much to my cats' dismay.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Play Career & Money Parenting